2014 NFL Draft Day Three Grades

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse


Devonta Freeman (8) carries the ball. Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

The 2014 NFL Draft came to a close yesterday after the Houston Texans made Memphis Tigers safety Lonnie Ballentine the intriguing “Mr. Irrelevant” of this year’s draft class, and this year’s affair was as fun to watch as we expected. There were several shocks, twists and turns, and the third day of the draft still managed to give us some interesting storylines. The Texans finally took a quarterback, the Cincinnati Bengals (not the Baltimore Ravens…we were trolled by ESPN, too) drafted A.J. McCarron, and teams managed to find some more bargains on the final day of an incredibly deep draft class. Below are grades for each team based solely on what they did on the third day of the draft, and you can read our grades for the first day here and the second day here.

Buffalo Bills B

Just a quick note: this grade does not include the Bills decision to acquire backup running back Bryce Brown from the Philadelphia Eagles. Although I was a bit surprised to see Randell Johnson go drafted, the Bills turned in a solid final day of the draft, snagging a couple of well-known prospects. Cyril Richardson fell into the  third day of the draft, but he didn’t last too long, as the Bills plucked him in the fifth round. He could easily turn into a major liability in pass protection, but he has plenty of upside as a run blocker. Speaking of upside, the other offensive line prospect they took yesterday simply oozes upside, as Seantrel Henderson has as good physical tools as No. 2 pick Greg Robinson. He isn’t anywhere close to being as good of a prospect as Robinson, though, and I actually thought Henderson would go undrafted. He’s probably the most frustrating player in the class, because he has massive character concerns after failing to fulfill his potential at Miami. I like the Bills decision to draft him, though. They also did a solid job of bringing on Duke cornerback Russell Cockrell in the fourth round, and he has good instincts and physical tools as a zone corner.

New York Jets B+

Manish Mehta’s bet backfired, as the New York Jets used up all of their draft picks and came away with a strong haul on the final day of the draft. John Idzik put together another strong draft this offseason, and the Jets spent their first two picks of the third day on wide receivers. Jalen Saunders has all the tools to be a very good playmaker in the slot at the next level, and I’m a big fan of that selection (I had Bruce Ellington rated higher, but Saunders is talented in his own right). Shaq Evans is a limited athlete who needs to do a much better job of catching passes in traffic, but he can develop into a solid No. 3 guy if he improves his hands; Evans understands the nuances of the position extremely well. They also snagged Nebraksa product Quincy Enunwa, who is a big sleeper at wide receiver. The Jets added two interesting edge rushers in IK Enemkpali and Trevor Reilly, and they also added Iowa State inside linebacker Jeremiah George. Before the draft, it was reported that Rex Ryan and the Jets were high on Tajh Boyd, and they drafted the developmental QB in the sixth. Guard Dakota Dozier and cornerback Brandon Dixon are two small-school prospects to watch in training camp.

New England Patriots B

The Patriots were also winners yesterday, and they are consistently one of the best teams in the NFL at drafting late-round prospects. They added a very solid running back to the rotation in the fourth round by pulling Wisconsin Badgers No. 2 back James White off the board, and he should immediately jockey for carries. If Stevan Ridley gets benched for another bout with fumbilitis next year, then White will get plenty of carries as LeGarrette Blount‘s replacement. Cameron Fleming was a steal ten picks later in the fourth, as I thought the run-blocking right tackle would go in the third round. I’m not a big Bryan Stork guy, but Jon Halapio had a very good career with the Florida Gators and could be the next solid late-round offensive lineman in New England. Zach Moore looks like a steal of a small-school prospect on paper, and the Patriots will hope that they he’ll be the impact backup pass rusher they’ve been looking for. Seventh-round selection Jeremy Gallon perfectly fits the profile of the kind of receiver the Patriots like going after. A productive slot guy in college, Gallon almost went undrafted due to limited physical tools. An undersized, late-round, productive Michigan product like Tom Brady (sorry, it was low-hanging fruit), Gallon will have to fight for a roster spot due to the depth and youth at WR on the Patriots.

Miami Dolphins B

So the AFC East had a good third day across the board, and I’m a huge fan of the Walt Aikens selection. He is a big-time sleeper at the position as a small-school cornerback from Liberty, and the Dolphins needed to add another cornerback to the mix with Dimitri Patterson gone. Jamar Taylor should make an impact next year after the second-round Boise State product did absolutely nothing last year, but he’s definitely not a sure thing. I’m not a big Arthur Lynch guy, but he should be a decent TE2 behind the much more athletic Charles Clay, who is a big part of the ‘Fins passing attack. Matt Hazel and Jordan Tripp were two other great small-school guys in this year’s class, and Tripp is a phenomenal value pick in the fifth round who could start if Dannell Ellerbe and Philip Wheeler don’t bounce back.

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Arizona Cardinals Atlanta Falcons Baltimore Ravens Buffalo Bills Carolina Panthers Chicago Bears Cincinnati Bengals Cleveland Browns Dallas Cowboys Denver Broncos Detroit Lions Green Bay Packers Houston Texans Indianapolis Colts Jacksonville Jaguars Kansas City Chiefs Miami Dolphins Minnesota Vikings New England Patriots New Orleans Saints New York Giants New York Jets NFL Draft Notes And Analysis Oakland Raiders Philadelphia Eagles Pittsburgh Steelers San Diego Chargers San Francisco 49ers Seattle Seahawks St. Louis Rams Tampa Bay Buccaneers Tennessee Titans Washington Redskins

  • Old Frog

    Wow! Can’t remember the last time I saw anyone give the Boys an A after draft day.

    • Scott.

      That is exactly what I was thinking.

    • http://www.musketfire.com/ Joe Soriano

      To be fair, it’s actually an “A” for their work on the final day of the draft. I’d put their overall grade at around an “A-” or maybe a “B+”, depending on how I feel about the trade up for Demarcus Lawrence. I like Lawrence, don’t like the haul they gave up for him.

      • Old Frog

        Well OK then…I’ll be sure to curb my enthusiasm.

        • http://www.musketfire.com/ Joe Soriano

          Larry David would approve of that.

          Haha, it was still a really good draft.

      • Old Frog

        I think the ideal plan was probably Shazier in the first and OG in the second but when Shazier went to the Steelers they had to come up with plan B. I guess they could’ve traded 16 and 47 to move up for Barr and then taken Jackson or Turner in the 3rd. Would that have been better?

        • David

          I would rather they jumped one pick in front of the Steelers to get Shazier and then go O-line in the 2nd or 3rd with only losing maybe a 4th and 7th or two to do it. Quite honestly Dallas has been pretty bad with their 4-5th round picks. The Steelers screwed Dallas in the 4th as we’ll by grabbing Bryant ahead of them which sucks because that led to Hitchens.

  • http://sbpra.com/paulvsuffriti Paul V. Suffriti

    Nice article….thanks Joe

    • http://www.musketfire.com/ Joe Soriano

      Thanks for the kind words, Paul. I hope you enjoyed the draft.

  • Larry

    Can’t agree with your Rams grade. No real thought there.

  • Ron Fulton

    I agree with you on the Bengals. As long as Lewis is there they will flounder.

  • ThreeOfive Logo Ellis

    Yall should watch robert herron highlights. He cud b betta da santana moss if he can do it on the next level.

  • Paul Newbold

    I don’t know Joe, while its nice to see a grade of B+ for the Jets, I’m just not certain. Somehow I feel Idzik could have come away with a bit more from this draft. He had 12 picks at his disposal, and in my opinion, only came away with a minimum of talent. The first two picks were solid, but from the third on, I became concerned. I have to question the corner in the third, while he may be fast, I thought they stretched a bit here, especially considering Desir was still on the board. The receivers will be improve the offense from the fourth round, but I felt they may have stretched on both of these picks, especially Evans. While over all I think it was a fairly good draft, somehow I’m a little disappointed. I guess we’ll have to wait and see what we have at rookie camp and beyond. The biggest steal for the Jets in the latter rounds has to be Dozier, if he can take on NFL coaching, and take the next step in his game, he may likely start for the Jets at guard at some point in the future.

  • Buddy guy

    Finally somebody that understands the Bears draft! I’m happy to hear you gradated so high I also thought the moves of Ferguson and Sutton really helped solidify our defensive line