4. Cincinnati Bengals – Which version of the defense will show up in the playoffs?
I'm not sure there's a better offense in football right now than Cincinnati's. From Weeks 3–10, the Bengals have performed in the 100th percentile in both EPA per play and success rate. It literally doesn't get any better than that.
But while Joe Burrow and this offense have been outstanding, the defense has been less impressive. Cincinnati ranks 16th in EPA per play allowed and 17th in defensive success rate this season, making it a pretty average unit overall.
And perhaps more concerning is how inconsistent this defense has been. The Bengals have put together impressive performances against Houston and Pittsburgh, but they've also struggled against Jacksonville and Tennessee. You never really know which version of this defense you're going to get on any given Sunday.
That inconsistency from your defense isn't ideal for a team with Super Bowl aspirations, especially considering the offenses Cincinnati could face in the AFC playoffs.
We know Burrow and this offense are capable of putting up points against anybody. But if the Bengals want to make a deep playoff run, they'll need their defense to show up consistently. So which version of Cincinnati's defense will we see when it matters most?
5. Denver Broncos – Is this formula sustainable in the playoffs?
The Broncos haven't lost a game since Sean Payton took back offensive play-calling duties in Week 5, but that doesn't mean all of Denver's offensive problems have disappeared.
To be fair, there has been some improvement. Denver's offense has gone from performing in the 39th percentile in EPA per play before the change to the 58th percentile since. But that's still far from an elite offense, and perhaps more concerning is that the Broncos have performed in just the 6th percentile in offensive success rate since Payton took over.
The running game hasn't exactly helped matters, either. Denver averaged just 3.6 yards per carry before the play-calling change and has averaged 3.7 since, hardly a significant improvement.
And while the Broncos have continued finding ways to win, it's been their defense doing much of the heavy lifting. Since Week 5, Denver's defense has performed in the 77th percentile in success rate allowed, consistently keeping games close while the offense finds ways to finish late.
When the playoffs come around, can the Broncos continue relying on their defense to keep them in games while waiting for the offense to come through? Or will Bo Nix and this offense need to find another gear for Denver to make a deep playoff run?
