Skip to main content

2026 NFL Season: The biggest concern for every current AFC playoff team

From Buffalo's defense to Kansas City's struggles protecting Patrick Mahomes, let's take a look at the biggest concern facing each of the AFC's seven current playoff teams.
ByEverett Rathe
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15)3
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15)3 | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
4 of 4

6. Pittsburgh Steelers - Can Aaron Rodgers lead a team on a deep playoff run?

This one feels pretty obvious to me. At this point in his career, can Aaron Rodgers lead an offense capable of making a deep playoff run?

We've certainly seen some encouraging stretches from Pittsburgh's offense this season, including a three-game stretch from Weeks 3–5 where it performed in the 87th percentile in EPA per play. But the consistency just hasn't been there, with the Steelers ranking 20th in EPA per play for the season.

And what makes Pittsburgh's offense so fascinating to me is its running game. The Steelers rank first in EPA per rush, but just 29th in designed rushing attempts. I'm not going to pretend I know more about football than Mike McCarthy and Aaron Rodgers, but it seems a little strange that one of the league's most efficient rushing attacks hasn't been a bigger part of the offense.

Rodgers has obviously accomplished just about everything there is to accomplish in this league, but he's also 42 years old, and this offense hasn't shown it can consistently perform at a high level.

If Pittsburgh wants to make some noise in January, can Rodgers turn back the clock, or will the Steelers need to find a way to take more pressure off their quarterback?

7. Cleveland Browns – Is this success sustainable?

Todd Monken has done an incredible job in his first season as Cleveland's head coach. The Browns are 6-4, currently have the final playoff spot in the AFC, and Monken is tied with Kyle Shanahan as the betting favorite to win Coach of the Year.

But when you look at the underlying numbers, this isn't exactly a team that blows you away statistically. Cleveland ranks 23rd in offensive EPA per play, 12th defensively, and despite having a winning record, the Browns have a point differential of -32.

And the most fascinating statistic about this team is that all six of its wins have come by four points or fewer, making Cleveland the first team in NFL history to accomplish that feat. 

You gotta give the Browns credit, though. They've consistently found ways to win close games, and that says a lot about Monken and the culture he's established in Cleveland in his first year. There's something to be said for a team that continues to close out close games.

Maybe Cleveland really has developed an identity where, if the game is close in the fourth quarter, you can trust the Browns to pull it out. But the underlying numbers paint a much more pessimistic picture of Cleveland's playoff chances, let alone its ability to make a deep run in January.

Add us as a preferred source on Google