Only a handful of days into Dallas Cowboys training camp, everyone is already rushing to judge Jaylon Smith, but don’t overreact in any direction.
There’s a viable chance that Jaylon Smith would’ve been a top-five pick in the 2016 NFL Draft in an alternate universe. Hell, he would’ve had a case to be picked ahead of Jared Goff and Carson Wentz as the top-overall pick in this universe. Instead, a horrific knee injury in the Fiesta Bowl — his final game at Notre Dame — put his football-playing future (much less his NFL prospects) in jeopardy. That, however, didn’t stop the Dallas Cowboys from taking a risk.
Jerry and Stephen Jones rolled the dice, taking Smith with the 34th-overall pick in the 2016 draft. Coming off of the torn ACL and, more worryingly, nerve damage in his knee, he sat out all of last season. However, with reports throughout the offseason about the nerve starting to re-fire and regenerate, the hope has been that he’ll play in 2017.
Given the outlook for the Cowboys defense in 2017, the notion of having Smith out there is enticing for easily discernible reasons.
More from NFL Spin Zone
- Dallas Cowboys made the trade everyone else should have made
- Pittsburgh Steelers rookie sleeper everyone should be talking about
- Anthony Richardson putting jaw-dropping talent on display immediately
- Denver Broncos’ stud wide receiver might be out for a while
- Washington Commanders: Three takeaways from win over Ravens
While Sean Lee is phenomenal, the rest of the linebackers leave something to be desired. Put simply, having Smith on the field with Lee and Anthony Hitchens is far more attractive than seeing Damien Wilson or Kyle Wilbur instead. This, of course, is assuming that Smith can play at a high level.
Coming off of such a debilitating knee injury and grueling recovery (mentally and physically), no one expects Smith to be 100 percent of the player he was for the Fighting Irish. However, even 85 percent of what he used to be is still a damn good NFL linebacker.
Subsequently, it was inevitable that eyes from Cowboys fans and around the league would be on Smith at the start of training camp. Just as unavoidable was the wild reactions that everyone would have. That’s exactly what happened on Monday when this clip out of Oxnard, CA and Dallas’ training camp made its way around Twitter:
Jaylon Smith pic.twitter.com/UiueNgVS3T
— Jon Machota (@jonmachota) July 24, 2017
There’s no question that this brief play from Smith doesn’t look great. For a player who was so explosive and instinctual in college, he’s nothing close to that there. Not only does he appear to be hobbled slightly, it almost appears as if he’s focused on running properly as opposed to making a play.
After seeing the contents of that clip, it figures that everyone started freaking out. Those who lambasted the Cowboys for selecting Smith cried vindication. Others who were optimistic became a bit downtrodden. Granted, there were some measured reactions, but many of them were not.
While those reactions aren’t unsurprising, they’re also asinine. Reacting to one play early in training camp for any player is ludicrous. When that player is playing for the first time in 18 months outside of minicamp workouts, it’s even more absurd. And if you need any proof of that fact, here’s a broader look at Smith’s work on Monday at training camp:
Sure, that first play still stands out with the limp and the ugliness of it. However, it’s also the outlier in that compilation. For the most part — aside from getting swallowed by Tyron Smith on a running play — Smith looks explosive and fast with little-to-no sign of a limp. Watching that grouping of clips, it would appear that there’s reason to be excited.
More from Dallas Cowboys
- Dallas Cowboys made the trade everyone else should have made
- Zack is back, good news for Dak and the Cowboys
- Dallas Cowboys: Are Dak’s interceptions cause for concern?
- Cowboys: Micah Parsons will be even more impactful in 2023
- 2023 NFL Season: It’s now or never for the Dallas Cowboys
There’s room for both optimism and pessimism in Smith’s case right now. However, what there isn’t a place for is snap-judgments and overreactions in either direction. There’s no reason to condemn the linebacker to the unemployment line after seeing one lowlight from camp. Conversely, there’s also no reason to crown him the next great NFL linebacker after a two-minute YouTube video.
Not only is there plenty more to see from Smith in terms of fans and Cowboys coaches, but he’s also yet to put pads on. According to Steve Wyche of NFL.com, he’s expected to put on pads and go full-contact when the time comes. And as has been reported previously in the offseason, that will be the most telling time for Smith’s recovery and potential impact.
Even at that point, though, it’s still unwise to dismiss or anoint Smith right now. There is more nuance to the situation than anyone not in the locker room or at every portion of training camp can ascertain.
For the Cowboys, it would be hugely beneficial to have Smith contributing to the defense in the 2017 season. As football fans, seeing the former Notre Dame star recover and make a successful comeback would be great. And of course for the many who despise America’s Team, they’d be happy if Smith wasn’t a special talent going against the other 31 teams in the league.
Next: NFL Power Rankings 2017: Training camp edition
No matter how this plays out, though, it’s decisively too early in late July to make any meaningful judgment about it. Right now, everyone would be best served to pump the breaks the next time a clip starts circulating. In the big picture of Smith’s situation and recovery, it likely doesn’t mean a damn thing.