Skip to main content

2026 NFL Season: The biggest concern for every current AFC playoff team

From Buffalo's defense to Kansas City's struggles protecting Patrick Mahomes, let's take a look at the biggest concern facing each of the AFC's seven current playoff teams.
ByEverett Rathe
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15)3
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15)3 | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
1 of 4

After breaking down the biggest concerns facing the NFC's current playoff teams, it's time to take a look at the other conference.

The AFC is stacked with top-tier head coaches, high-flying offenses, and fanbases desperate to see their team represent the conference in the Super Bowl.

With that in mind, let's take a look at the biggest concern facing each of the seven teams currently occupying a playoff spot in the AFC.

All advanced statistics courtesy of Statyx.

The biggest question facing each current AFC playoff team

1. Buffalo Bills – Is the defense good enough to win a Super Bowl?

The Bills are 8-1 and currently hold the No. 1 seed in the AFC, and it's pretty easy to understand why. Josh Allen and this Buffalo offense have been fantastic this season, ranking fourth in EPA per play.

And honestly, Buffalo's offense doesn't have much left to prove. The Bills have consistently had one of the best offenses in football throughout the Josh Allen era, but the defense has been a different story, particularly in the playoffs. In their last five postseason eliminations, Buffalo has allowed an average of 32.2 points per game, surrendering at least 27 points in every loss.

This season, the Bills rank just 17th in EPA per play allowed and 22nd in defensive success rate. But there's actually been some pretty significant improvement recently.

Over their last four games, Buffalo's defense has performed in the 100th percentile in EPA per play allowed and the 94th percentile in success rate allowed. That's some incredible production, and there's certainly reason to be encouraged by how this unit has played.

But those four games came against Baltimore with Tyler Huntley at quarterback, along with Minnesota, Las Vegas, and New York. Those other three offenses all rank outside the top 15 in EPA per play, with Minnesota and Las Vegas both ranking outside the top 20.

So I'm not entirely convinced we've seen enough from this unit to declare it championship-caliber. Can Buffalo's defense maintain this level of play against the AFC's best offenses when it matters most, or will Allen once again be forced to carry the Bills through the playoffs?

Add us as a preferred source on Google